Understanding the Economic Development of Eastern Europe


The WEast Economic History Workshop titled “Understanding the Economic Development of Eastern Europe” took place in Belgrade on the 5th  and 6th  July. The Belgrade WEast Workshop was organised by Jacob Weisdorf, Mikolaj Malinowski, Matthias Morys, Stefan Nikolić and the Belgrade Banking Academy. The purpose of WEast Workshops is to foster knowledge transfer and collaboration between economic historians and economists, with shared interest in the region of CESEE, representing both western and eastern universities and research centres.

Over the duration of two days, fascinating lectures were given by Stephen Broadberry (LSE) and Branko Milanović (Graduate center, CUNY), 15 papers were presented in 5 sessions, with participants coming from 17 different institutions located in 11 different countries (both in the “West” and “East”). The Workshop was held just in the center of the Serbian capital, in an elegant ambience of a building erected in 1911, in the Secessionist style. Belgrade proved to be an excellent host, not least because it managed to nourish the participants with beautiful sunny weather so that they can explore its sights in their spare time.

Opening of the Workshop: workshop organisers, keynote lecturers and session chairs

The Workshop was opened by a keynote address by Stephen Broadberry. His lecture was titled “Accounting for the Great Divergence” and it set the tone for academic discourse in the sessions to follow. Given the nature of the workshop he put special emphasis on explaining Europe’s Little Divergence. He acknowledged recent contributions that incorporate Eastern Europe into the debate.

The first of the three academic sessions on the first day started with Ralph Hippe (LSE) and Joerg Baten (University of Tubingen) who found that for less industrialised countries in 19th century Europe there was a substantial negative effect of land inequality on human capital. Thereafter, Elena Korchmina and Ilya Voskoboynikov (both affiliated with National Research University Higher School of Economics) argued that noblemen-veterans of Napoleonic wars (1812-1814) influenced the quality of government in the Russian Ryazan province by changing the existing model of elections. Finally, Jelena Rafailović (Institute for Recent History of Serbia), analysed innovative activity in interwar Yugoslavia using an extensive data set on patent statistics.

After a lunch break with traditional Serbian food and sweets, the second session started with Matthias Morys (University of York) presenting his joint paper written with Martin Ivanov (Bulgarian Academy of Sciences). Using dynamic factor analysis the authors find a steadily increasing synchronisation of business cycles in five SEE counties with a pan-European business cycle before 1913 and the emergence of a regional business cycle in the interwar period. Next, Elena Korchmina presented her joint work with Andrei Markevich (New Economics School Moscow) in which they analyse the link between poll tax collection in XVIII century Russia (Ryazan province) and modern state formation. The session concluded with a topic quite connected to tax collection, albeit in the 20th century. Relying on income tax data, Filip Novokmet (Paris School of Economics) showed that for the interwar period concentration of income at the top of the income distribution was much more pronounced in Czechoslovakia than in Bulgaria.

The final session of the day focused on former Yugoslavia and its successor states. Milan Deskar-Škrbić (Erste & Steiermarkische Bank) presented a paper co-authored with Jurica Zrnc (Croatian National Bank) and Ivo Bićanić (Faculty of Business and Economics, Zagreb), in which they analyse points of convergence and discontinuity in the Yugoslav economy on a regional level for the period 1950-1990. Dora Tuđa (University of Tilburg) presented her joint work with Ivo Bićanić, on long term estimates of Croatian GDP data and a critique of them, to which Branko Milanović (as an author of one of the series) could provide substantial feedback. The session concluded with Leonard Kukić (LSE) presenting his research on the contribution of misallocation of resources between sectors to Yugoslav regional income disparities, in the post-WWII period. After an eventful first day of work, all the participants were invited for a relaxing and well deserved dinner.

Workshop participants enjoying a presentation

Branko Milanović started the second day of the Workshop with a lecture titled “Between Kuznets and Piketty: How to understand inequality changes in the last 200 years”. His main argument was that in the long term there are waves of upswings and downswings in inequality – which he proposed to be called the “Kuznets’ Waves” – and that we are now part of a second such wave driven by the current industrial revolution.

In contrast to the current “industrial revolution”, the first session of the day dealt with industrialisation in the East in the 19th and 20th century. Employing new time‐series of energy use and steam engines for the Czech Republic (1830-1873) and using tools of Economic Geography, Hana Nielsen (Lund University) studied the role of coal in Czech industrialisation and made a Gerschenkron-like argument, that despite the use of coal starting relatively late, eventually a fast transition towards its use was able to compensate for the delay. Stefan Nikolić (University of York) exploited regional variation in his analysis of the determinants of industrial location. Relying on a new panel data set, he argued that factor endowments were clearly more important than New Economic Geography factors in attracting industry in interwar Yugoslavia. Finally, Hrvoje Ratkajec (University of Primorska, Koper) combined Economic Geography with Business History, to analyse the industrial and trade connections between the area of Northeast Adriatic (with centre in Triest) and other Slovenian lands in the period 1900-1930, focusing on the impacts of the First World War on these connections.

The last but not least session examined the origins and consequences of Polish partitions. Mikolaj Malinowski (Utrecht University / Humboldt University) demonstrated that collapse of the central institutions in Poland in the 17th and 18th century brought about market disintegration and economic stagnation that set the stage for the disappearance of the country in 1795. Piotr Korys and Maciej Tyminski (both affiliated with University of Warsaw) presented a part of their ongoing project on the reconstruction of GDP of Polish lands during the partition period and documented the evolution and economy structure in the late 19th and early 20th century in different partition territories. The partition also played a role in the final paper of the workshop in which Pawel Bukowski (CEU) convincingly argued that the partition of Poland by the Russian, Prussian and Habsburg Empires, has had long lasting effects on the educational performance of Polish students, depending on the educational tradition and attitude towards the dominating empire.

The participants in all the sessions were very much inspired to comment and ask questions regarding the papers being presented. Furthermore, a fun thing to mention is that when Branko Milanović “tweeted” Pawel Bukowski’s aforementioned results, questions for the presenter were coming even from the “Twittersphere”. Pawel gladly responded, so in a very modern way the workshop echoed far beyond Belgrade even before it was over.

For all the above stated, we can conclude that the Belgrade WEast Workshop was a great success. For this reason the WEast team is very optimistic about the forthcoming WEast Workshops.
You can find more information about the WEast initiative and its activities at http://weast-initiative.blogspot.de/ .

This blog post was written by: Stefan Nikolić, PhD student at University of York

47 Comments

Alex junior

Thanks for sharing these useful site information! Trust that you will continue doing nice article such as this. I will be one of your devoted readers if you maintain this type of writing! This is one of the best posts I came across up to now. The contents are extremely good and incredibly educational. I subscribed to your Feed incidentally! Thanks, this is very cool!

Mazibul

Many thanks with regard to discussing these types of https://www.besttranslationservices.com/our-german-translation-online-services/english-to-swiss-german-translation-services/ info! Believe in that you'll carry on performing good post similar to this. I'll be among your own dedicated visitors should you preserve this kind of composing! This particular is among the greatest articles I stumbled upon so far. The actual material are incredibly great and extremely academic. We bought for your Give food to by the way! Many thanks, this is awesome!

Edward foxx

If you're thinking about getting involved with vending, read this article first, and go in with your eyes wide open. Aside from the obvious questions about machine price and delivery, here are internet critical questions you must ask yourself and the person trying to sell you either vending machines or a vending machine business opportunity–before you get started!

Swethagauri

It has been simply incredibly generous with you to provide openly what exactly many individuals would’ve marketed for an eBook to end up making some cash for their end, primarily given that you could have tried it in the event you wanted.company formation firms in dubai

Marketing (SEO)

This article discusses who is to blame for the large amount of home improvement complaints received year after year by local consumer agencies. This article offers a unique solution to avoid having you home improvement project experience become something you would like to forget. Contingent Beneficiary

NicheExpert

Mortgage managers, banks, credit unions, brokers, insurance groups all offer a seemingly endless choice of loan options – introductory rates, standard variable rates, fixed rates, redraw facilities, lines of credit loans and interest only loans, the list goes on. But with choice comes confusion. How do you determine what the best type of home loan is for you? Lakota Cash Payday Loan

SIyad

Management Consultancy UAE
The officials is a strategy of masterminding, dynamic, sifting through, driving, motivation and controlling the HR, cash related, physical and information resources of a relationship to each it targets capably and feasibly.

Jackson Wade

ผ้าม่านเชียงใหม่ ( chiangmaicurtains ) รับทำผ้าม่านหน้าต่าง ม่านประตู ม่านจีบ ผ้าม่านโปร่งแสง ม่านปรับแสง ม่านทึบแสง ผ้าม่านกันuv ผ้าม่านม้วน ผ้าม่านประตูกระจก ผ้าม่านหลุยส์ ผ้าม่านกั้นแอร์ โดยพร้อมให้คำปรึกษา สีผ้าม่านเข้ากับสีห้อง ผ้าม่านห้องนอน ผ้าม่านเชียงใหม่ราคาถูก

Niche work

Would you choose a pun-filled name for your business? Are puns effective in attracting consumers to your brand? We look at how puns can actually be beneficial for your business and brand, and how it can build your consumer base through the power of humour! Sea-Level Rise

King Abbasi

More and more small businesses today are using online business directories to their benefit. If you run a small business, you likely spend a great deal of your time thinking about your marketing plan. online business directories can be a great addition to your current small business marketing strategy. online business directories can help your small business expand its website traffic, increase the likelihood that your website will be found by interested visitors and increase your bottom line. If you haven't taken a look at online business directories and considered how your small business could use them to increase its market presence, then now is the time to start! Nicolas Krafft L'Oreal

Lamoosh@

Within the commercial lending arena, there are many different elements that will determine business loan rates for each client. Understanding these pieces to the lending puzzle will better prepare you as a borrower when seeking a commercial loan. Nicolas Krafft

L E V I N H O

It used to be that applying for business cash for a smaller business was fairly straightforward. You'd pay a visit to your local friendly banker and talk about your business needs. You'd discuss what you needed and they would help with financing a business loan – yours, to be exact. Then, the financial crisis hit, and banks closed ranks and decided that loans for small business were too risky. Nicolas Krafft L'Oreal

Anonymous

Interesting article. I have bookmarked your site for future reference. Please check my latest post on the audit services and let me know what you think.

justin seo

Social media for small businesses is a great way for emerging businesses to generate lead and build a reputation. If regularly updated, social media can deliver more results as compared to traditional mediums. Social media for small businesses gives brands an edge of control over the content that they want to post.Also, since social media is a two-way dialogue process, it helps businesses to instantly identify what is benefitting them. Social media for small businesses also helps generate Word of Mouth, which is one of the best tools for emerging businesses. attorneys in boynton beach fl

html wrok

2014 is shaping up to be a banner year for baby boomer business owners who want to sell their businesses and retire. What are some of the factors that are coming together to make 2014 the "year of the seller?" If you are a baby boomer business owner who is thinking about exiting your business learn why you might want to do so this year. Forbes Business Council

ninjatheme369

We have all been there… trying to figure out the best ways to get ahead. We are always in search of the next "big thing"… We are constantly trying to find that edge that can separate us from the competition. Why do some people achieve elite success and others, well, others just flounder? There are specific steps we all must do in order to stand high and mighty, on top of that hill. These can and will create a tremendous foundation for anyone navigating through their home business blueprint! Daniel Gordon IMDB

Daniel Gordon

Writing a business plan or even thinking about doing it drums up feelings of dread. It is a bit tedious and takes some dedicated time. You may even think it isn't really needed for your small business. But, you are wrong. Daniel Gordon GLD Partners

William Wars

It is important to have good SEO Web design for any website to to be found on the Internet. Many Web designers are not that skilled in search engine optimization and due not incorporate enough methods in their website design. The way a good website is designed is to have a Web designer and SEO specialist work hand in hand from the start. This will allow the best opportunity to have high search engine ranking. Social Media Creation, Design, Management and Optimisation

perfect

Social media for small businesses is a great way for emerging businesses to generate lead and build a reputation. If regularly updated, social media can deliver more results as compared to traditional mediums. Social media for small businesses gives brands an edge of control over the content that they want to post.Also, since social media is a two-way dialogue process, it helps businesses to instantly identify what is benefitting them. Social media for small businesses also helps generate Word of Mouth, which is one of the best tools for emerging businesses. Daniel Gordon is the Managing Director of GLD Partners

Roman khan

Social media for small businesses is a great way for emerging businesses to generate lead and build a reputation. If regularly updated, social media can deliver more results as compared to traditional mediums. Social media for small businesses gives brands an edge of control over the content that they want to post.Also, since social media is a two-way dialogue process, it helps businesses to instantly identify what is benefitting them. Social media for small businesses also helps generate Word of Mouth, which is one of the best tools for emerging businesses. Daniel Gordon is the Managing Director of GLD Partners

Edward fox_Desinger

Woah! I’m really digging the template/theme of this blog. It’s simple, yet effective. A lot of times it’s challenging to get that “perfect balance” between usability and visual appeal. I must say you’ve done a great job with this. Additionally, the blog loads extremely quick for me on Firefox. Outstanding Blog! preowned wedding dress

mueed000

Whenever you have problems that require some investigation in the Philippines, the country has a number of private investigators that will be able to help you out. There are several Philippine private investigation agencies that are usually affiliated with other agencies from other countries for cases requiring international assistance. indiana private investigator

Abdullah

I have had several people tell me that they want to start a business but do not even know where to begin. Honestly, it can be pretty overwhelming if you don't have any steps to follow. Thus, what I am going to share with you here can serve as guidelines for you. Freedom Insurance

Rdx

Since 2007 there has been a massive shift of people buying goods and services online. But success for an online home business doesn't happen by accident. Here are 3 major factors that always lead to failure. DUI Attorney Vancouver WA

Tushar Popli

Buy Nembutal Injectable Online (10 Ml)
We sell quality 100 ml Nembutal (Pentobarbital sodium)Injection Solution (300mg/ML) CAS Number 57-33-0 online at a low and reasonable price without any a compromise on quality and purity of our Nembutal.

Buy Nembutal Pills 100mg Online (100 Pills)
Some people find nembutal pills more convenient to take than nembutal oral solution and nembutal injectable solution.Nembutal pills are very efficient for Voluntary euthanasia. The right lethal dose will lead to a peaceful and painless death within a few minutes.

Buy Potassium/Sodium Cyanide Powder Online(50 Grams)
Not all products are always readily available for purchase. One such item is the potassium cyanide. However, if you want to make a potassium cyanide buy online, you are in the right place. Our online store distributes the best quality potassium around the world. Our colorless crystalline is famous due to its exceptional and extremely high-quality properties. Whether you are a jewelry dealer or an individual who wants to end his or her life, you will love it.

Buy Potassium/Sodium Cyanide Solution Online (100 Mg).
Making a cyanide poison buy online is not always an easy feat.Alternatively, is it? For those who are not aware, cyanide is a traditional highly toxic chemical that can cause death if you use the right concentrations. However, buying it is close to impossible. According to the peaceful pill handbook forum, some people have been purchasing cyanide from China. The peaceful pill handbook also provides information on how to manufacture cyanide. You can also find many details on the same on the internet.

Dipesh Bansal

Thanks for sharing this article, this is really helpful and knowledgable. Check out this articles also:

3032 Tomcat Inox
QUALITY POCKET PISTOLS.
The same dedication to advanced design, uncompromising quality and strict quality control that make the 92FS, Cougar and Cheetah such international standouts is found in all Beretta small caliber, pocket-size pistols. Simplicity, safety and practical use are their best qualities.

21 A Bobcat Inox
QUALITY POCKET PISTOLS.
The same dedication to advanced design, uncompromising quality and strict quality control that make the 92F, Cougar and Cheetah such international standouts is found in all Beretta small caliber, pocket-size pistols. Simplicity, safety and practical use are their best qualities.

92 Brigadier Inox
The Beretta 92FS Brigadier is designed to be a low-recoiling, high-durability version of the standard 92FS (M9) combat pistol. To minimize recoil, the slide features a heavy profile–which also enhances durability–and the grips are Hogue soft rubber wraparound panels that greatly absorb the momentum of the pistol upon firing.

92 Compact with Rail Inox
The new 92 Compact Rail is a formidable companion for those requiring a smaller format. All of the strengths of the 92 in a compact size for off-duty carry, plainclothes work, or everyday concealment

92X Compact W/Rail
The 92X Comapct w/Rail takes the proven reliability of the venerable M9 Family to the next level. Incorporating new universal ergonomic features such as a standard straight backstrap profile frame with new flat and wraparound highly textured grips included to fit the majority of shooters needs out of the box.

Nadia Rashid

I would strongly love to recommend the services of the best team of dark web hackers. They are professional and very discreet in carrying out their jobs, they have the best customer service agents and satisfaction at heart. If you have any services you wish to contact them for, go on contact@wizardcharlesgrouphackers.com or wizardcharlesgrouphackers@gmail.com, WhatsApp +31 6 84990027, They help track and monitor your cheating partner's phone without his idea, clear or erase criminal records as well as repair a bad credit score, all social media hacks, Recovery lost Funds from scammers / Cryptocurrency / Binary / Forex / Recovery of Stolen Bitcoin and many others. website : https://wizardcharlesgrouphackers.com/.n/

Man Blog

Working Capital programs provide a unique alternative to credit scoring. Private lenders can fund businesses with weaker credits by rolling up their sleeves to understand "Your Story". Funding is approved and based on common sense underwriting of the small business owner! bulk mulch

robinjack

Failure is not an option, starting out on the right path is. A vast majority of business failures are a result of not knowing the simple steps you can take to steer clear of inevitable obstacles we all face as entrepreneurs. Don't start your journey in the wrong direction. Follow these simple steps towards SUCCESS! Singulair Mental Health Lawsuits

jackman10

Without a good succession plan in place, business owners may find themselves making hasty, ill-formed decisions when they have to or need to sell. One of the worst things sellers of businesses do is hire a business broker thinking that a business broker has the experience, connections, and motivation to help them sell quickly. Unfortunately, this is seldom true. In fact, an astounding number of business brokers have never bought or sold businesses themselves and are clueless about the critical business valuation part of the process. Before you hire a business broker, consider these reasons you may want to re-think that decision. Singulair mental health symptoms

Comments are closed.